The Power of Play: Why Interactive Play Beats Food Rewards in Dog Training

In the world of dog training, rewards are an essential part of encouraging positive behaviour. While food treats have long been a favourite for dog trainers and owners alike, there’s another equally (if not more) effective reward structure: interactive play. As a professional dog trainer in England, I’ve seen first-hand the power of play as a reward structure, and in many cases, it offers advantages that food simply can’t match.

Why We Use Rewards in Training

Before we dive into the benefits of interactive play, let’s first understand the purpose of rewards in training. Dogs are naturally motivated to repeat behaviours that are rewarding to them. When we reward desired behaviour, we’re reinforcing the idea that such actions lead to something positive. Whether it’s a treat, a game of tug, or a good scratch behind the ears, the reward encourages them to continue behaving in that manner.

For years, food has been the go-to reward because it’s quick, easy, and universally appealing to most dogs. However, relying solely on food can have its limitations. That’s where interactive play comes into the equation.

The Benefits of Interactive Play in Training

1. Stronger Bond Between Dog and Owner Interactive play is a social activity that requires participation from both the dog and the owner. Whether it’s a game of tug, fetch, or hide-and-seek, play is a bonding experience that strengthens the relationship. While a food treat is a one-way transaction, play builds a deeper connection and mutual enjoyment.Dogs thrive on the attention of their owners, and play is a fun way to give them that attention. It not only serves as a reward but also as a form of communication, making the dog feel valued and understood. Over time, this bond makes your dog more responsive to training and instructions.
2. Increased Motivation While food is motivating, it can become predictable. Some dogs may become less enthusiastic over time, especially if they’ve just eaten or the treat isn’t particularly exciting. On the other hand, interactive play taps into a dog’s natural instincts for chasing, tugging, or problem-solving, which can be far more engaging.Play can vary in intensity and excitement, keeping your dog eager and alert. The unpredictability and personal involvement keep the experience fresh, which maintains motivation during training sessions.
3. No Risk of Overfeeding One of the biggest downsides of using food rewards is the potential for overfeeding, especially when you’re doing multiple training sessions a day. Even small treats can add up over time, contributing to weight gain or upsetting a dog’s balanced diet.With interactive play, there’s no caloric cost. It’s an excellent way to reward your dog while avoiding the pitfalls of over-reliance on food treats, which is particularly important for dogs prone to obesity or those with dietary restrictions.
4. Mental and Physical Exercise Interactive play doesn’t just serve as a reward—it also provides both mental and physical stimulation. A game of fetch encourages a dog to run, jump, and focus on the task at hand, while tug-of-war provides a mental challenge alongside physical exertion.Engaging the brain during training can improve problem-solving abilities and increase focus. Incorporating physical exercise through play also has the added benefit of keeping your dog fit, healthy, and happy, while burning off any excess energy.
5. Enhances Focus and Engagement Many dogs, especially working breeds or high-energy dogs, need more than just a quick treat to stay focused. Play is a highly engaging reward that can refocus a dog’s attention in a way that food sometimes can’t. By breaking up a training session with a brief play reward, you can maintain your dog’s focus and stop them from becoming bored or distracted.In fact, using play as a reward can build anticipation. Your dog knows that a fun game is coming, making them more willing to perform the desired behaviour with enthusiasm.
6. Flexibility and Variety Play rewards come in all shapes and forms. Tug, fetch, chase, or even scent games can be incorporated into training sessions depending on what excites your dog the most. This variety means that your dog never knows exactly what’s coming, keeping them engaged and eager to find out what’s next.This flexibility is also useful when working on different types of training exercises. For example, a game of chase might be great after a recall command, while tug can reinforce impulse control.
7. Reinforcing Natural Drives Dogs have natural prey and play drives that, when engaged correctly, provide immense satisfaction. Interactive play taps into these instincts, especially with games that mimic chasing or tugging behaviours. This allows you to work with your dog’s natural instincts, rather than relying solely on food rewards, which don’t fulfil these inherent drives.For dogs with high prey or play drive, these games become the ultimate reward, even outmatching food in certain situations.

When to Use Interactive Play as a Reward

While play has numerous advantages, there’s a balance to be struck. Some dogs, especially puppies or very excitable dogs, may get overstimulated by play, making it hard for them to calm down and continue with the training session. In such cases, play should be used strategically, perhaps as a reward at the end of the session or after mastering a particularly challenging task.

It’s also essential to tailor the play to the individual dog. Some dogs love a good game of tug, while others prefer a chase. Pay attention to your dog’s preferences and adapt your playtime rewards to suit their natural inclinations.

Conclusion

While food rewards will always have their place in training, interactive play offers a dynamic, engaging, and healthy alternative that strengthens the bond between dog and owner. By incorporating play into your reward structure, you not only motivate your dog but also give them the mental and physical stimulation they need to thrive. The next time you reach for a treat pouch, consider swapping it for a toy or a quick game, and watch as your dog’s excitement and enthusiasm for training skyrocket.

Happy training!

For all our tug toys click here